Posts

Lisa's Method: A New Arrangement For Calculating Slope

Image
Lisa’s Method: A New Arrangement For Finding Slope The National Council of Teachers of Mathematics continues to advocate for more student-centered mathematics teaching (NCTM, 2000). One of my dreams as a mathematics teacher and tutor is to have a student come up with an innovative approach to doing or thinking about some mathematics. And one of my nightmares is hearing of or seeing a student do something creative and be ignored or slapped down by an insensitive or ignorant instructor who fails or fears to consider that a student’s ideas about something might be of value. One of the worst aspects of “sage on the stage” mathematics teaching is its propensity for minimizing opportunities for students to do any thinking in class that strays from the teacher’s directed and generally very beaten path. Recently, I had one of those much-desired opportunities to see a student spontaneously come up with what was, to me at least, an original approach to something that is easy for and familiar to ...

Pinning The Blame On The Wrong Donkeys: A Response to "The Problem With Math Education"

Image
The latest post on the blog " The Math Mojo Chronicles " states in part: The Problem with Math Education Filed under: math education, public schools; Author: Brian; Posted: December 8, 2008 at 8:18 pm; Well, of course it’s not the problem, just one of many, but here it goes… Somehow along the way, people got the feeling that math is supposed to always be right, and that math teachers are supposed to know all the answers. Math has gotten the reputation of being an authoritarian science. I don’t think this is the fault of mathematicians, I think it is the fault of many math educators who have tried to turn mathematics from an art and science into a “subject.” Math education is all too often about “standards” and “curricula” that students take “tests” about that they are “graded” on. If Archimedes was to take a high-school math test today, he would be unfamiliar with the jargon, and would find little value in the trite little multiple-choice and partial credit nonsense that pas...

What Can Division Tell Us About Multiplication? (Part 2)

Image
Preface This post has been sitting in the hopper since the beginning of November. Due to a number of conflicting writing projects and a major presentation I've been preparing to give on Dec. 1., I'm at a point where I need to either fish or cut bait with this now, pending a lot of reading that I don't have time to do immediately. My decision today is to post this "as is," with the major investigation of existing research left hanging fire until I have time to do it real justice. So for some readers, this second post may disappoint, not getting to what I personally think is the nitty-gritty that must be explored to determine whether Keith Devlin's heuristic columns on multiplication and repeated addition are simply provocative pieces that fail to lead to urgent rethinking of how we present multiplication to students in K-12, or if in fact he has put his finger on something mathematics teacher-educators and elementary and middle school teachers need to take very...

What Can Division Tell Us About Multiplication? (Part I)

Image
In my tireless pursuit of the question raised this past summer by Keith Devlin in a series of columns in the MAA MONTHLY (" It Ain't No Repeated Addition " (June 2008); "It's Still Not Repeated Addition" (July-August 2008); and " Multiplication and Those Pesky English Spellings " (September 2008)) regarding the potential harm of leaving students with the belief that multiplication is nothing more than repeated addition, I am doing extensive reading about how children learn about, think about, and are taught to think about mathematics and the connection amongst and differences between the operations. One leg of this journey brings me to consider division. There are a number of ways to think about division, but the two "big ideas" looked at in school mathematics are the partitive or "fair sharing" model and the quotative or "measurement" model. Partitive Division With Whole Numbers As a quick overview or review, let...

Does This Mean That The Phone Company Did Kill Kennedy?: Even More on Keith Devlin, Multiplication, and Repeated Addition

Image
A recent post on the continuing conversations, fights, and debates inspired by Keith Devlin's recent trio of columns on problems he and some mathematics educators (in England, if not elsewhere) see with teaching multiplication-as repeated-addition (or, variously ONLY teaching it that way and never leading students to see that multiplication either is not repeated addition or is a lot else besides repeated addition) to elementary students, let me to write a response that gets at some of what I've been thinking about as I read those British researchers. Below is a re-edited version of my reply: A crucial point I've tried to make previously in various places: there is a serious problem with the absolutist language a lot of folks in this debate insist upon using and which Prof. Devlin falls into at times (and hardly just at math-teach: check the comments at lets play math ; good math, bad math , and any number of other blogs where this issue has been debated for several month...

Plus ça change (plus c'est la même chose): language and The Math Wars

Image
Jackson Turner Main In recent posts (see both) at math-teach@mathforum.org, veteran "math warrior" Wayne Bishop has complained about "so-called Constructivists" and other alleged abuses of "jargon" by what I imagine he thinks of as "so-called progressive educators," and the like. He's very incensed about such language, all the while representing groups like Mathematically Correct and Honest Open Logical Debate (HOLD) whose very names are fascinating examples of propaganda and dissembling, and whose major tactic in the "Math Wars" is to find new epithets for the educators, programs, practices, and ideas they want to destroy. These are folks who have been tormenting the English language into pretzel-like bits of obfuscation, perhaps the most outlandish being Bishop & Friends' attempt to paint those who support progressive mathematics...

Changing Order of Topics: An Example From Practice

Image
Some day, my princess will come. And she'll be passionately interested in discussing questions of actual teaching practice in mathematics classrooms. Actually, of course, many such exist, but getting them together on this blog or in open, active public forums, having the time to participate actively, etc., isn't always a trivial task. For full-time teachers, time is always at a premium, and while there are many good resources on the Internet, tracking down what would really be productive for one's own work can be difficult. From my perspective, one of the shortcomings of even the best conversations about practice, however, is the lack of access to specific classroom data, particularly video with supporting documentation (teacher journals, samples of student work, assessment instruments, observer notes, etc.) that would allow other practitioners to engage in deep analysis of what goes on in mathematics teaching based on common access to the same materials. As a former litera...